American Horror Story: Freak Show After Show Season 4 Episode 5 "Pink Cupcakes" | AfterBuzz TV

looking back, Ryan was right about this season 5 clue. he is a bastard!!! that top hat was alluding to Gaga (her applause video there's a few scenes of her in a giant tophat).

does anyone know  if full episode of 1 & 2 are on here and how can i get to them? I have been looking cause I missed the first 2 i only found episode 2 and they wanted to charge me to watch it.  thank you

why is this after show commentary so akward, I mean not just this episode. the constant akward silence, the way everybody specially the guy in the middle look very uninterested and how the guy with glasses talks like so slow.

This by far was the best episode of the season thus far. The acting was phenomenal this week. Angela Bassett killed her scenes. I don't think we are done with the jimmy/Desiree thing since wouldn't that be quite a revenge; getting your fathers wife pregnant but maybe they both just was consoling each other. Dandy and Gloria are the reason this season is amazing. Sandy is so gleefully psycho it's downright charming but you buy into people may not take him as a threat, I think reginas tone made sense. Simd families back then treated their help like family. Like Dora raising sandy. The help usednto be mother than the actual mothers of the children and if Gloria let Regina play with dandy as kids the obviously have a previous relationship. Not to mention Gloria getting personal with her demonstrates a familiarity. I can't wait for Regina to show up. She may end up being the twins savior since I'm pretty sure dandy just sees them as playmates and confidants so won't kill them. I also think we will learn more about dandy through her interactions with him as a kid. Overalls wasn't loving the season but it's definitely set up some interesting things this episode. And seriously??? You guys are just now realizing Dell is gay? lol picked that up the episode he was introduced

There are alot of references to different serial killers. The serial killer John Wayne Gacey as mentioned before on Afterbuzz AHM was the killer clown. Dandy seems so far as the amalgamation of Ted Bundy (look looking, suave and intelligent) and Jeffery Dhamer (killed Gay men and used acid)

Research skull and bones, some would consider to be the darkest of secret societies.

Ryan Murphy always goes for classic and cliché horror settings when choosing his theming: Haunted house, asylum, coven, carnival. Because of this, the only logical next horror cliché I can think of is a lake-side teen summer camp which could open up possible expected tropes such as serial killers and monsters in the lake but could also move onto whatever Murphy wanted (e.g Cabin In The Woods craziness). I know it doesn't incorporate the top hat but hey ho there ya go 🙂 

I think Emma Roberts has some type if freak in her cause have pay attention to her eyes
They have two different colors almost like Dandy's mom but her eyes is one normal and the other a slash type of eye

Maybe the "top hat" clue is about the freemasons? Like a secret government? What do you think?

In the opening I believe the Jersey Devil makes a cameo. It's very brief and he doesn't wear a top hat.

I heard another top hat theory on reddit that isn't quite as obvious.  In Freemasonry, top hats are often associated with the position of Worshipful Master as they are the only member allowed the privilege to wear one, or another appropriate head covering to signify their leadership within the lodge. It is also common for Worshipful Masters to receive top hat related trinkets and gifts on either the day of their installation or as a going away present. In other countries, especially within certain systems in Germany, top hats are worn by all members of the lodge.
Since the Freemason's in the US date back to the early 1700's, there's a very wide time frame for when this season could take place.  It might not even be Freemason's exactly, but some other kind of secret organization with a dark past.

I officially look forward to this after show as much as AHS every week, great job guys:)

I'm thinking that Season 5 is gonna focus on Jack the Ripper because of the Top hat and Gloria mentioned something about Jack the ripper to Dandy after she discovered that he killed Dora.

1st if your going to a freakshow, no one would care about some damn singing sorry Elsa.

2nd if Dell likes male body parts and turns out Desiree doesn't have a penis, why try and kill the doctor. If you're with her because she has a penis and it turns out she doesn't then why do you still want to be with her. Your clearly hooking up with guys so I don't see the point of what Dell is doing.

3rd Dandy could've got some before he killed the guy, clearly the dude is sexually frustrated.

4th I didn't think of anything of how Gabby's character was talking I was just happy to see her and I didn't think she came of sassy or anything.

5th Is every guy on this show gay like it wouldn't surprise if Jimmy had a gay moment next week. Lol

5

Like the episode and the discussion.
Made me laugh at what David said, "Sexy….Save the wiener."   

Perhaps my thought about Season 5 and the whole top hat easter eggs, all I think about it could set within 19th Century era. Personally I like to see where they would go with that, the 19th Century of the United States. But I do like the 1920's idea or possibly early than that.

The tree that Dandy's father was hanging from was a Japanese Maple.

My theory on the top hat is that it could be about freemasonry in the United States. I did a search on youtube and found a documentary called freemasonry in america, and they wear top hats during their ceremonies. It could be something that would connect with coven, since coven was mostly female dominated, freemasons are male dominated. And could also have something to do with the witch hunters in coven. I did some thought on this, and I think it could be a possibility. Who knows if I'm right, but it would make a good season I think.

Hey guys you know how at the end of every season Sarah paulson is always sitting down talk to someone like in the past two wouldn't it be funny is at the end of this one and bett and dot are still alive cut to 30 year later a woman is writing a book called freakshow and she has a scare on one side of her body where one twin is cut off the other head and this is all a story what do you think?